Get More Great Stuff!

Join over 90,000 subscribers! Get a free weekly update with exclusive content.
No spam, ever. Enter your email here:

Does discussing feedback help you change course for the better?

No. Paradoxically, it makes you more “entrapped” in your previous biases:

Entrapment occurs if people persist with losing courses of action. In two experiments, we show how elaborating social feedback (i.e., premature praise or forewarning regarding the chosen course of action) can have paradoxical effects on entrapment. The participants acted as head of a translation department and had to choose one out of four possible translation strategies for their employees. After choosing, they read four arguments (presumably written by former participants) which were either all in favor of the strategy chosen, all against it, or mixed. Half of the participants only read these arguments, whereas the other half elaborated on them by providing written comments (Experiment 1). The results showed that elaborating on other persons’ arguments led to stronger entrapment, independently of whether the arguments were positive or negative. This pattern was due to biased argument processing: Whereas confirming thoughts were generated for positive arguments, negative arguments were refuted. Experiment 2 confirmed that this biased argument processing caused subsequent entrapment. These results indicate that elaborating any type of argument can lead to heightened entrapment and, hence, forewarning can backfire.

Source: “When forewarning backfires: Paradoxical effects of elaborating social feedback on entrapment in a losing course of action” from Journal of Behavioral Decision Making

Here is the best use of feedback I’ve ever heard.

Related posts:

How much do teachers improve with experience?

How to quickly and easily become a better person

Here’s how to improve learning while you sleep

Are we more sympathetic when people’s problems are due to a disease?

Here are the site’s most popular posts of all time.

You should follow me on Twitter here or subscribe to this blog’s feed. If you’re a regular reader please support the blog by doing your book and movie shopping at the store. You’ll find all my recommendations there.

About Eric Barker